How is the Purity of Butter Tested?

Last Updated on March 12, 2024 by Partha Protim Choudhury

What is butter?

Butter is a dairy product made from the fat and protein components of milk or cream. It is typically churned or whipped to separate the butterfat from the buttermilk. Butter has a rich, creamy texture and a distinct flavour, making it a versatile ingredient in cooking, baking, and spreading on bread or toast. People commonly use it in various cuisines around the world. You can find it in both salted and unsalted varieties. Butter is prized for its taste, texture, and ability to enhance the flavour of dishes.

How is pure butter made?

Making pure butter involves a straightforward process that starts with fresh milk. First, the milk is allowed to sit until the cream rises to the top naturally or is separated using a centrifugal separator. The cream, containing a high concentration of fat, is then collected. Next, the cream is churned vigorously. During churning, the fat globules in the cream are broken down and start to clump together, separating from the liquid portion known as buttermilk. The churning continues until the fat globules form larger clusters of butter.

The butter is then washed with cold water to remove any remaining buttermilk, which helps prevent spoilage. After washing, the butter is kneaded or worked to remove excess water and to achieve the desired texture. Finally, the butter is shaped into blocks, sticks, or moulded into various shapes, ready to be packaged and distributed for sale. The result is pure butter, free from additives or preservatives, with a rich and creamy taste.

What are the quality parameters of butter?

In India, the quality of butter is typically categorised based on factors such as purity, freshness, and processing methods rather than formal grading systems like those found in the United States. However, butter in India is commonly classified into two main categories:

1. White/Pure butter: The first sign of pure butter is that it is made solely from cream, without adding any other ingredients. Experts consider pure butter to be of high quality. People often often prefer it for its rich taste and texture.
2. Processed butter: Processed butter may contain additional ingredients such as salt, preservatives, or flavourings. Though widely popular for use, especially in commercial food production, experts generally consider processed butter to be of slightly lower quality than pure butter due to the added ingredients.

These categories are not formal grading systems but informal classifications used in the Indian market to distinguish between different types of butter based on their ingredients and processing methods.

What are the factors affecting the purity of butter?

Several factors can affect the purity of butter:

• Source of milk: The source of milk used in making the butter can influence the quality and purity of butter. Milk from healthy and well-fed cows is more likely to produce pure butter.
• Processing methods: The methods used to process butter, such as pasteurisation, homogenization, and churning, can impact its purity. Minimal processing techniques tend to preserve the natural qualities of butter.
• Additives: Some butter products may contain additives such as salt or preservatives, which can affect their purity. Pure butter should ideally contain only cream or cream and salt for salted butter.
• Storage conditions: Improper storage conditions, such as exposure to heat, light, or air, can lead to spoilage or contamination of butter, reducing its purity.
• Adulteration: Adding substances like margarine, vegetable oils, or water to increase volume or reduce costs can cause adulteration of the butter, compromising its purity.
• Regulatory compliance: Compliance with food safety regulations and quality standards plays a significant role in ensuring the purity of butter produced and sold in the market.
• Handling and packaging: Hygienic handling practices and proper packaging can help maintain the purity of butter by preventing contamination from external sources.

How is pure butter adulterated in the market?

In the Indian market, butter is sometimes adulterated through various deceptive practices aimed at increasing profits or stretching the product. Some common methods of butter adulteration in India include:

1. Addition of vegetable oils: Unscrupulous producers may mix butter with cheaper vegetable oils like palm oil, coconut oil, or soybean oil. This dilutes the butter’s quality, alters its taste, and reduces production costs.
2. Incorporation of margarine: Some may add margarine, a cheaper alternative made from vegetable oils, to butter to increase volume and profitability. While margarine resembles butter, it lacks the rich flavour and texture of pure butter.
3. Mixing with ghee: Ghee, clarified butter widely used in Indian cuisine, may be blended with butter to deceive consumers. This adulteration method is difficult to detect as both ghee and butter have similar characteristics.
4. Adding starch: Adding starch to butter is a deceptive practice to increase its volume and reduce costs. Starch from corn or wheat is mixed with butter to stretch the product without adding nutritional value. This allows producers to sell more butter while using less actual butter.

What are some tests that we can do to check the purity of the butter at home?

At-home butter purity check tests can help consumers verify the authenticity of butter. Here are a few methods you can try:

• Melt test: Pure butter melts easily at room temperature, while adulterated butter may not. Place a small amount of butter on a clean, dry surface and allow it to come to room temperature. Pure butter should start melting relatively quickly, whereas adulterated butter may take longer to melt or remain solid.
• Visual inspection: Examine the colour and texture of the butter. Pure butter typically has a rich, creamy colour ranging from pale yellow to deep golden yellow. It should have a smooth, creamy texture without any lumps or grains. Adulterated butter may have an inconsistent colour or texture due to the presence of additives or fillers.
• Ingredient check: Read the ingredient list on the packaging carefully. Pure butter should contain only one ingredient: cream or milk. Avoid products with additional ingredients like vegetable oils, preservatives, or artificial additives, as these may indicate adulteration.
• Smell test: Pure butter has a rich, creamy aroma characteristic of dairy products. Adulterated butter may have a different or unpleasant smell due to the presence of additives or fillers. Take a whiff of the butter to assess its aroma and freshness.
• Water test: Place a small amount of butter in a glass of warm water. Pure butter will float on the surface of the water, while adulterated butter may sink or disintegrate. This test can help detect the presence of added water or fillers in the butter.
• Starch test: Performing a starch test on butter is a straightforward method to check for adulteration. To conduct the test, spread a small amount of butter thinly on a clean surface, and add an iodine solution to it. If the butter contains starch, indicating possible adulteration, the iodine solution will turn blue or purple upon contact. However, if the butter is pure and free from starch, there will be no colour change in the iodine solution. 

The Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI) recently shared a video on YouTube demonstrating how to differentiate between adulterated and unadulterated butter through testing.

Consumer awareness is vital for making informed decisions, especially in an era where food adulteration is widespread. Despite ongoing debates about butter’s status as a superfood, its inclusion in bulletproof coffee, its potential eye health benefits, and its consistent ability to enhance the flavour of toast and parathas are undeniable. By staying knowledgeable about food quality and making wise choices, consumers can effectively navigate the complexities of the modern food industry and prioritise their health and wellness.

Disclaimer: Medical Science is an ever evolving field. We strive to keep this page updated. In case you notice any discrepancy in the content, please inform us at [email protected]. You can futher read our Correction Policy here. Never disregard professional medical advice or delay seeking medical treatment because of something you have read on or accessed through this website or it's social media channels. Read our Full Disclaimer Here for further information.