Quick Take
A social media post claims that patharchatta (Bryophyllum pinnatum) can dissolve kidney stones in two days. We fact checked and found the claim to be False.
The Claim
An instagram post makes a very unreal claim that Drinking patharchatta juice or using its extract can dissolve kidney stones in just two days.
Fact Check
Can Patharchatta dissolve kidney stones in just 2 days?
No, the claim is not supported by any reliable scientific evidence. The idea that patharchatta plant is beneficial for stone and can break it in just 72 hours has spread across social media and home remedy forums. But no clinical research confirms this. Kidney stones are solid crystals that form inside your kidneys. They don’t dissolve easily or quickly, especially not with one herbal remedy.
The speed at which a kidney stone passes or breaks down depends on many factors: the size and type of the stone, your body’s hydration levels, urine output, and whether you’ve had stones before. For example, small stones under 5 mm may pass naturally within days or weeks, but larger stones often require medical help.
Even if someone felt relief after taking patharchatta for two days, there’s no way to prove the herb alone caused it. The timing might just be a coincidence.
Dr Ubaid ur Rehman, General Physician at Holy Mission Clinic in New Delhi, explains, “There is no scientific proof that patharchatta plant benefits or dissolve kidney stones within two days. Although certain compounds in the plant may support kidney function, breaking down or passing stones typically needs more than just herbal remedies.”
Dr Ganesh Srinivasa Prasad P, Consultant Nephrologist at Narayana Health City, Bengaluru, says that no home remedy can promise to prevent or cure all kinds of kidney stones. “The best way to lower your risk is by drinking plenty of water, cutting down on salt, keeping a healthy weight, eating calcium-rich foods, and avoiding foods high in oxalates. People prone to uric acid stones should also reduce their intake of red meat, sugar, refined carbohydrates, alcohol, and quit smoking,” he advised.
Aayushi Agarwal, Certified Dietician & Diabetes Educator said “Patharchatta (Bryophyllum pinnatum) is valued in Ayurveda for kidney stone relief due to its diuretic and anti-inflammatory properties. While some anecdotal reports highlight benefits, no clinical evidence supports complete stone dissolution in three days. Effectiveness depends on various factors, and unsupervised use may delay medical care, increasing risks of obstruction, infection, or kidney damage.”
What does science really say about patharchatta plant for stones?
Some lab studies show promise, but there’s no solid proof it works in humans.
Researchers have studied patharchatta for its diuretic, anti-inflammatory, and lithotriptic (stone-breaking) effects. Some studies using animal models and lab tests have shown that the plant may help reduce the formation of calcium oxalate crystals, which are the most common type of kidney stones.
For example, a lab study published in the Journal of Ethnopharmacology found that extracts from the plant may help prevent the growth of kidney stones in rats. That sounds hopeful, but here’s the catch: these studies were done in test tubes or animals, not in real people. And none of them say anything about working in just two days.
Doctors rely on human trials to recommend treatments. And so far, no human studies have confirmed that patharchatta can dissolve stones, quickly or otherwise. Until then, it remains a folk remedy, not a proven cure.
Why do some people believe Patharchatta works like magic for kidney stones?
Because it’s been used in traditional medicine for years, and stories spread fast.
In many Indian households, patharchatta is seen as a home remedy for kidney stone or is called “stone breaker” or “pashanbheda”, a name that literally means stone-splitting in Sanskrit. This nickname itself creates high expectations. Grandparents and local herbalists have passed down its use for generations, especially to treat urinary discomfort or small stones.
Today, the internet has made this belief go viral. Short videos, WhatsApp forwards, and blog posts often show people boiling patharchatta leaves, drinking the juice, and claiming instant relief. These personal experiences, while heartfelt, aren’t verified or supported by medical research. They’re anecdotal, not scientific.
How safe is patharchatta? What you need to know before trying it
It’s not risk-free. Some people should be extra cautious.
While many people drink patharchatta juice without trouble, that doesn’t mean it’s safe for everyone. Here’s what you need to consider:
- Pregnant and breastfeeding women should avoid it. There’s no safety data for these groups.
- People with diabetes should be cautious. Patharchatta might lower blood sugar levels, especially when taken with diabetes medication.
- It may cause stomach upset, nausea, or allergic reactions in some people.
- Long-term or excessive use hasn’t been studied well and may carry unknown risks.
If you’re already on medication for kidney health, blood pressure, or diabetes, combining it with herbs like patharchatta could lead to side effects. Always check with a doctor before using it, especially if you have an existing health condition.
When to stop and see a doctor?
If symptoms continue or worsen, seek medical help immediately. Don’t assume this home remedy for kidney stone is working just because you’ve started it. Watch out for warning signs that you need professional treatment, such as:
- Pain that gets sharper or doesn’t ease
- Fever, chills, or vomiting
- Blood in your urine
- Difficulty in passing urine
- Pain that radiates to your groin or lower back
These could be signs that the stone is too large or stuck, or that an infection has developed. Waiting too long while depending only on herbs can lead to kidney damage or even hospitalisation.
Doctors may prescribe painkillers, hydration therapy, or medications that help stones pass. In more serious cases, procedures like shock wave therapy or surgery might be needed. And none of these should be replaced by herbal remedies alone.
Final Words
Patharchatta plant for stone has potential. It may offer some comfort or help support kidney function. But there’s no medical proof it can dissolve kidney stones in just 2 days. Relying only on home remedy for kidney stone could delay real treatment, and that’s risky. If you’re dealing with kidney stones, combine smart habits with medical advice. Nature can support healing, but it shouldn’t replace science.
Disclaimer: Medical Science is an ever evolving field. We strive to keep this page updated. In case you notice any discrepancy in the content, please inform us at [email protected]. You can futher read our Correction Policy here. Never disregard professional medical advice or delay seeking medical treatment because of something you have read on or accessed through this website or it's social media channels. Read our Full Disclaimer Here for further information.
