Quick Take
According to a Facebook reel, Bhumi Amla tea could efficiently dissolve kidney stones. We verified the claim and found it to be mostly false.
The Claim
A widely shared Facebook post captioned “Stone Breaker plant” advertises a herbal remedy for kidney stones prepared by boiling Bhumi Amla leaves. Even while Bhumi Amla is known to have modest diuretic effects, not everyone with renal calculi may benefit from it.
Fact Check
What exactly are kidney stones? Why should they be taken seriously?
Renal aggregates, also referred to as kidney stones, are solid lumps that form within the kidneys. They typically manifest as supersaturation of the following urinary components:
- Uric acid
- Calcium
- Oxalate
- Cysteine
- Phosphate
They have become a health concern since they are associated with dehydration, enhanced sodium consumption, weight-related challenges, and reduced physical activity. Individuals who have a family history of nephrolithiasis, metabolic issues, or repeated UTIs may be at risk.
Smaller ones might not cause any symptoms, but those sufficiently large to obstruct urinary flow might exhibit symptoms. The primary clinical symptoms include severe pain in the abdomen, nausea, vomiting, and haematuria. If renal calculi-related urinary blockage is not dealt with right away, it might result in kidney damage or infection.
Does Bhumi Amla tea have the potential to dissolve kidney stones?
No, not always. Bhumi Amla, botanically identified as Phyllanthus niruri and commonly referred to as “stone breaker”, is a frequently used folk remedy for kidney stones. This could be explained by its diuretic and antilithic (anti-stone) characteristics, which may reduce the crystallisation of stone fragments in the urinary system and promote their passage and dissolution. Furthermore, the botanical extract may help remove stones after lithotripsy, prevent calcium oxalate crystals from aggregating, slightly reduce the size and amount of stones, and improve various urine metabolic parameters without exhibiting a major negative impact.
Despite the aforementioned benefits, Bhumi Amla lacks large-scale randomised controlled trials to establish it as a primary therapeutic intervention for kidney stones. Moreover, unlike the clinically validated options, the at-home preparation lacks standardisation in terms of dosage, safety, and efficiency.
Consultant Nephrologist Dr. Bhanu Mishra of Delhi’s BLK Max Hospital concurs, pointing out that not all stone types can be dissolved by the combination mentioned above. Even though consuming calcium and drinking enough water may help prevent kidney stones from forming, the notion that an at-home formulation could effectively dissolve and eliminate existing kidney stones is inaccurate.
Even while Bhumi Amla tea may be used as an adjunct to lifestyle measures and medical therapy, one should not depend on it alone for handling renal calculi without medical assessment and appropriate conventional care.
Is there a universal cure for all kidney stone types?
No, even while certain unregulated organic substitutes are promoted as universally effective Ayurvedic remedies, their significance is confined to social media. This is due to the fact that no medical system suggests a universal remedy for kidney stones. Like any other medical condition, they call for a distinctive therapeutic approach. These are frequently medicated based on their anatomical location, size, composition, and associated symptoms.
Although certain at-home remedies may enhance urine flow or perhaps reduce recurrence, there is no generic solution to treating kidney stones. Lithotripsy, medicine, hydration, and surgery are all part of the comprehensive therapeutic strategy that remains the cornerstone of kidney stone management.
Persistent consumption of generic home remedies for kidney stones is discouraged by Dr. Sharad Malhotra, Head of Hepatology, Gastroenterology, and Therapeutic Endoscopy at Aakash Healthcare in New Delhi. Despite the potential for some small benefits to digestive or urinary health, Dr. Malhotra notes that there is insufficient scientific evidence to support the use of these unregulated therapies as a substitute for conventional medical care for renal calculi.
Generic web promises may be highly deceptive, so those who are more susceptible need to carefully evaluate them. Such online alternatives need to be validated by trustworthy sources.
Are online kidney stone remedies an acceptable means to get rid of them?
No, not really. High-risk patients use unproven at-home options because they are easily accessible and reasonably priced, and they may prefer not to see a doctor.
Some of these internet treatments might alleviate symptoms temporarily, but they shouldn’t be used as the main treatment for kidney stones. This could be explained by the lack of comprehensive clinical trials that are required to validate their efficacy and safety.
Dr. Archana Daftardar, a Consultant Nephrologist, Hypertension specialist, and Transplant physician at Renova Hospitals in Kompally, Hyderabad, supports this by highlighting that there are several misconceptions about kidney stone prevention and treatment. Alternative therapies that haven’t been tested could make the condition worse rather than better. It is advised to consult qualified Ayurvedic or allopathic practitioners.
As a result, depending entirely on unapproved remedies could cause problems and delay required therapy. Only under professional supervision may home-based therapies be used as supportive care; timely medical evaluation is required to establish the appropriate course of action.
What is the most effective way of handling kidney stones?
As previously established, kidney stones necessitate a well-thought-out strategy. In most cases, nephrologists combine the following:
- Clinical Assessment
- Case-specific therapeutic intervention
- Lifestyle alterations
The primary approach usually includes pain control, consuming sufficient fluids, and monitoring for the spontaneous passing of the smaller stones. Doctors may also suggest some medications to prevent stone recurrence. Keeping up a healthy diet can aid in their medical management.
Nephrologists and urologists work together when the stones are larger, symptomatic, and obstructive. Depending on the condition, medical practitioners may employ lithotripsy or endoscopic removal. Usually, the removal is confirmed with a follow-up.
Therefore, long-term prevention and preservation of renal health are just as important as immediate relief in evidence-based medical care of renal calculi.
Disclaimer: Medical Science is an ever evolving field. We strive to keep this page updated. In case you notice any discrepancy in the content, please inform us at factcheck@thip.in. You can futher read our Correction Policy here. Never disregard professional medical advice or delay seeking medical treatment because of something you have read on or accessed through this website or it's social media channels. Read our Full Disclaimer Here for further information.
